Even a simple green cloth from your local art store will work just as well. (Streamlabs OBS) App seems to turn my pictures with transparent backgrounds to white (yes its PNG) Tech Support So I want to have an image show on stream whenever someone follows/subs, and i cropped the image and turned the background to transparent and saved as PNG, but when i upload it to streamlabs it always turns the transparent part to white. transparent image vs. solid image If you are an experienced graphic designer, or work with one, we suggest you create a solid file, and then create a layer mask and use a soft brush to feather the edges to create a faded look. How do I make the actual capture background of OBS transparent, so then when I record it it is being picked up as a transparent rather than a solid background? http://imgur.com/AKhyQ6b, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Is there any way to make background transparent on OBS? 1. We would create (or use) a mask that conceals the sharp, 90-degree corners of your webcam. Want to see a new shape included in the kit? It'll come in a Zip file. Image Source While complex masks might take a bit more practice, the process is virtually the same no matter what shape youre making: Just remember everything in white will be shown; everything in black will be hidden. How would I go about fixing that? What about webcam frames with rounded corners, or cutouts and indents along the borders? All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. However, if youre using advanced stream overlays like many of the ones youll find in our store youll need to go a bit further. Before long, tens if not hundreds of thousands of creators will be using masks on-stream. prprlive transparent background on streamlabs obs - YouTube Skip navigation 0:00 / 2:15 prprlive transparent background on streamlabs obs eChroma 28 subscribers Subscribe 84 Share 3K. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Now that we have everything set up, we have to key and pull it out. Could you upload the image on imgur or something similar? Then in your preview window hold down ALT and drag the box to do a Crop to edit out . I wish the program background could be transparent instead of black, for the purpose of using the output in other applications such as keying graphics over other videos. Some times PNG have weird internal corruption that only shows up with random programs. I guess I can't buy this game to use then? Well show you some advanced tips & tricks shortly, but first lets cover OBS. Get started by downloading Streamlabs Desktop. I just figured it out!! From the settings tab navigate to "Game Overlay". More freedom and flexibility to customize alerts, Logitech Services S.A. All Rights Reserved. Change your Webcam Shape How to Use Image Masks, download one from our free pack of 21 streamer masks, How to create masks with Photoshop (optional), How to use basic masks in OBS & Streamlabs, Tips & tricks for using advanced mask designs, They look amazing and will help your stream, Masks help to remove some of the dead space within a traditional webcam frame. Right click on the layer you wish to apply a filter to then select 'Filters'. For example, my camera view is configured to 19201080, so my screenshot should be 19201080. Get Streamlabs Desktop go live in minutes! I can enable chromakey for webcamera, but not for application. Thanks for any tips! Privacy Policy. Millions of high-quality images, video, and music options are waiting for you. and our Spin da wheel with adjustable sectors; Free Curtains widget. Weve created a free mask kit, which includes: Each kit includes TONS of unique webcam shapes and borders and were taking requests too! They arent for everybody, and by no means is it required, but we want to provide this guide to help you set up your green screen if it is right for you. Now, videos you create have this green in places where you want it to be transparent. Copy and paste a web-based URL in the browser source settings menu. In OBS studio, right click the source, click on "Filters" Add a 'chroma key' filter and then, without adjusting anything else, change the 'opacity' field to your desired level of transparency 1 Reply PsykodeliksGaming 6 yr. ago I almost paid for an XSplit Chroma Key program. obs Png obs logo Png. Press J to jump to the feed. Keep experimenting until you find the perfect mask + frame combination for your stream. stream overlay facecam yellow. You're now ready to add any one of a long list, but check out our 5 best filters for OBS: Color Correction. And they come with some special benefits: So how do you find image masks? Second, we wanted to share some positive news: In the past few weeks . obs clipart obs vector black and white obs obs webcam frame obs studio obs icon obs overlay facecam border obs obs frame templats obs obs live streaming obs logo. OBS and Streamlabs Commit to Long-Term Collaboration. Use a photo editor like GIMP to reexport it. Good to know, thanks! New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Now that youve got your new image mask in hand, lets start setting it up. There is no one correct answer for these settings as everybodys lighting situations different, hair is different, skin color is different, and background is different, which is why youre going to have to play around with it until you refine it down. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Browser source interaction is a particularly handy feature when you need to make changes or update the web page you are displaying on the fly. In OBS, you do this with the color key filter. Learn how to create your own loyalty points in Streamlabs Desktop Cloudbot, Learn how to effectively moderate your chat with Mod Tools, Logitech Services S.A. All Rights Reserved. Jpg files don't have alpha support I think. Within OBS Studio, at the time of upload, you can rotate sources spinning them on their axis of the top left, right, bottom left, right and from the centre, and you can spin sources by as little increments as one tenth of a degree rotation! I have the same problem as mquiroz. Get free Obs studio icons in iOS, Material, Windows and other design styles for web, mobile, and graphic design projects. Filters can be applied to any image, media, or video capture source. Open the recording in Windows Media Player or any other media player you use. When I have that ticked it works to cut the grey background out. There is no place for a transparent "color" in the common video formats/encoders, so you have to pick and declare one of the existing colors as "transparent". twitch clipart image twitch overlay. Choose Image Source for static graphics; choose Media Source for animated. Now select your camera from the source list. Make sense? When I have that ticked it works to cut the grey background out. Everyone on the team is incredibly thankful and humbled by your enthusiasm for what we do. If you're using OBS Studio, when you do the Game Capture after selecting the window for Stream Avatars there should be a littl tickbox that says "Allow Transparency". Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). Select a blue and a cyan color for your foreground and background colorsor select any colors you prefer! Create an image filled with exactly this green and use this as bottom source in OBS. 567 Images. 1260x700. Go to the "Sources" tab, press the "+" icon, then select "Video Capture Device". 2. Control Your Live Stream From Your Phone with Streamlabs Controller, Tips to Navigate COVID-19 as a Live Streamer. Now you can click, scroll, type and interact with a website directly in our software as you would any other browser. As a live streamer, you are in a unique position to provide meaningful interaction with your audience during these uncertain times. This FREE bundle contains 21 image masks for changing your webcam shape. Reading Time: 9 minutes. For the Color setting, set . Mylenium 1 Like Translate Report Correct answer by Byron Cortez Community Expert , Apr 20, 2020 If is video, export it in QuickTime or Avi container with codec Animation which supports alpha channel. Name it, then locate the overlay file on your PC. Customizable animations for streamers and video creators. Create an image filled with exactly this green and use this as bottom source in OBS. (I use an old, old version.. if it ain't broke, don't fix it!). This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Once you have done this, restart your computer and re-open Streamlabs. In the meantime, share your mask creations with us by tagging us @VBI on Twitter. 2. Is it something within C2 export, or like Streamlabs that's at fault? 2021-12-24. . Adding a browser source lets you display web-based content on-screen by quickly copying and pasting the URL into your browser source settings. Keep practicing and youll be miles ahead of the others. Access everything you need for professional live streaming, recording, video editing, highlighting, sharing, monetization and more. found it @ Filters | Chromakey | Smoothness. For many streamers, a basic understanding of webcam masks is enough to get by. 1. For more information, please see our To fix this issue you will want to be . How to use the Image Slideshow in Streamlabs OBS 1. streaming clipart png obs studio. Here's what setup looks like on Streamlabs OBS: Add your webcam source, if you haven't already. 903 Images. after some fiddling i found out that changing the editing software solved the problem, thanks anyways. If you'd like to talk about any of these topics with me personally, please let me know with a DM on Twitter. I went live during a work meeting with my first attempt at using non-verbal phrases. Then, you should click the gear-shaped icon in the StreamLabs application and choose "General" settings. offers. Try and download as a png file. The Company will assist with the relocation and visa process. Once you have added your source, right-click on the source to bring up a menu. Add two video sources Make sure the video layer you want to use an image mask on is the top layer. Set your green screen up as far away from you as possible reduce the amount of spill on your clothing. To add your frame and adjust color, follow these steps: Pretty easy, huh? So in our example, "money transparent" will get you GIFs like these: Downloadable GIFs for Streamlabs 3 Reply More posts you may like r/Twitch Join Rotating sources in your streaming software can be essential to ensuring placement of images, pictures, GIFs, video files, browser sources, overlays and text files etc are perfectly placed on. Evenly light your green screen so Streamlabs Desktop has an easy time keying or pulling the green out so you look nice and crisp. So you can literally rotate a single degree within OBS Studio (or even less if you like!). This ensures that. Today, we are excited to incorporate browser source interaction to Streamlabs Desktop. Any way to get it to stay transparent? Well show you step-by-step how to create and set up your camera mask. How To Make Transparent Background for Stream/Record by Using OBS Studio | TipTalks #1 Bloody GameDev 19.1K subscribers Join Subscribe Share Save 43K views 5 years ago Join our Whatsapp Group. Crop/Pad. what do i do, My version of OBS doesn't have a transparency option.. Privacy Policy. stream overlay facecam yellow. Once again, well start out with Streamlabs OBS: Now your camera, image mask and webcam frame can all be used in any scene youd like! And then I have a little program that shows a keyboard, and lights up keys on the keyboard, whenever I strike them on my physical keyboard. I checked a few things: - Is it in right file path- Will it work work with JPEG- Asked a few streamers on Twitch for some advice. That PNG has a checkerboard background, it's not actual transparency. Ever wondered how some streamers use cool shapes for their camera like circles, triangles or vertical rectangles? Click Browser Source, name it, and press Add Source. For instance, if the website you want to display requires a password or CAPTCHA, youll now be able to type directly on the page using our browser source interaction functionality. Streamlabs changes its name after backlash from Twitch stars and open source software maker | TechCrunch Streamlabs changes its name after backlash from Twitch stars and open source software. While your webcam scene is still selected. man i would love to watch a good solid video tutorial of this, and how to solve each problem people might run into. Take a screenshot from the recording, maintaining the exact dimensions of your view. Download and use it for your personal or non-commercial projects. Unfortunately it didn't showed up and I was confused. Sound tricky? It might ask you to rewrite some existing files and that's fine. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Dont know if it should/would make a difference but I use krita to make sure ive got a transparent background. /r/Twitch is an unofficial place for discussions surrounding the streaming website Twitch.tv. https://twitter.com/DisciplesTweetsLike my Facebook page! 1. I thoroughly enjoy connecting with fellow believers, as well as non-believers. Adding webcam masks is a fun and simple way to make your stream stand out. So basically, I have an image of a keyboard, with certain keybindings. In this example we will add a circular mask to our webcam source. Broadcasters are getting more creative, experimenting with new, out-of-the-box stream layouts. 2. Your kit also includes 21 optional webcam frames, which you can customize with your unique colors. Transparent GIFs Or if you're wanting your Streamlabs GIFs to be transparent, then try adding the keyword "transparent" after your main keyword search. HH-MM-SS. Custom Content. michaelc is right of course, it would be great to have a direct way to set the background transparency. Obs PNG. Adding Sources Into OBS Studio In OBS we'll see the scenes in the bottom left, and the sources next to it. Cookie Notice In OBS, record a snippet of your main camera view. Thanks again for watching! Download icons in all formats or edit them for your designs. 0 0. In this tutorial guide, were going to show you: Dont have Photoshop? Everything outside will be hidden. For streamers that need to login to view a website, browser source interaction is an extremely useful feature. Chroma key is one of them. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. I couldn't scroll, but had to resize my window and could access the correct + sign to select Chroma Key. Be warned: sometimes only having light in the front isnt sufficient. In Streamlabs Desktop, navigate to Sources while you are in the studio tab and click the plus sign to add a source. Additionally, I stream on Twitch Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday evenings. We are recruiting for Project Managers: Transparency Data X2 who will be based at our head office in Hoboken, NJ. For more information, please see our Just found it by myself too. Explore Streamlabs Web Suite Develop your brand, monetize your channel, and beyond. Featuring unique shapes like circles, diamonds, triangles, vertical rectangles and more. https://www.twitch.tv/DiscipleLIVEFollow me on Twitter! The image you posted is a JPG. In the app you want to use this video, you need a feature to convert this color to transparent. I seem completely unable to set it to transparent, yet I've seen other programs able to do it. Meanwhile, graphics providers (like us) are incorporating more unique webcam options into their designs. https://bit.ly/2oZ2uW3About Disciple Gaming:This channel and all of its corresponding media accounts are designed to provide a quality forum to discuss geeky topics like tech and games, as well as the Gospel, and applying God's word and will into our daily lives. Remember to follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube. More about this later, when we go into the software. This window will let you interact with the webpage like its own browser. For example, lets say we want our webcam to have rounded corners. Downloads: 13. Click Browser Source, name it, and press Add Source. Unless you want to edit the animations and remove the green section yourself with an image editor which will take a bit of time which will probably give you the best result.. your best bet is to set up a chroma key filter for that specific green. This allows you to create cool shapes and cut-outs along your camframes borders. It is commonly used on the live streaming service Twitch but can also be modified for other live broadcasting platforms. Popular Searches. https://bit.ly/2JYH6YjFind me on Twitch! twitch overlay facecam. Also includes 21 optional webcam frames to add over your image mask. Open up Streamlabs Desktop, go to your camera source, right-click on it and go to filters. Yep, that that helped. December 22, 2020 by David Whelan. If so, you may have many questions. Right click camera, filters, + but there is no Chroma key option. Download 6469 free Obs studio Icons in All design styles. Check out our companion video tutorial for a step-by-step guide: Webcam masks are filters within OBS and Streamlabs that allow you to hide parts of your camera source. Open OBS on your computer and add an input in the lower left. Its easy to set up your webcam mask in Streamlabs or OBS. Copy and paste a web-based URL in the browser source settings menu. Transparency on OBS Studio. Even though the CSS code within Streamlabs is set to: body { background-color: rgba (0, 0, 0, 0) !important; margin: 0px auto; overflow: hidden; } It still doesn't work. https://imgur.com/a/sHClk41 (OBS)https://imgur.com/a/zuHsMyS (PS)https://imgur.com/a/BY0JPo6 (W10 Viewer). In this menu, click the filters option. Similar With youtube png transparente 0 0. Streamlabs Ultra One single subscription, premium features for 8 creator apps. Download OBS Shadefilter. The picture above is an example of the gallery area on the Alertbox settings page. Just to show the issue. and our There are a few small differences for OBS Studio, but overall the process is quite similar: Need some webcam masks for your stream? Carousel wheel with images . Webcam masks in OBS and StreamElements (OBS.Live) are nearly identical, with a few small differences: And there you have it! Well, you can either create one of your own, or you can download one from our free pack of 21 streamer masks. Start personalizing your broadcast graphics. Step 8 Use the Gradient Tool to apply a gradient to our bottom polygons. In case of a video capture device or media source, use the effect filters list, not the audio/video filters list. Luckily, by reading this youve got a head-start on the competition. Well also show you how to create a webcam scene, which will house all your webcam elements and apply them across multiple scenes at once. 1. White, visible. Hi Reddit!I've a question about uploading my PNG file to OBS. JavaScript is disabled. Animated overlays, on the other hand, are packed with seamlessly looping videos with gorgeous effects and animations - that's your . Setting up a green screen is mainly done through software, however, you do need a couple of supplies to get you started. Add a transparent image overlay to OBS screen recordings or video streams Jonathan Cutrer 361 subscribers Subscribe 32K views 7 years ago In this video, I will show you how to create and overlay. clean and green clipart live. Any way to show avatars and game like on screenshot in store? Static versions of our overlays include mostly .png images with transparent background - it's a great choice if you don't want to overload your PC. Now that youve mastered the basics plus some advanced tips & tricks youre ready to take things to the next level. Personalize stingers with your logo and brand colors. The first method is to create an NDI stream of the main (stream) output and/or the preview output (studio mode) in OBS Studio containing all sources visible and the mixed final audio stream, by enabling the NDI Main and/or Preview Output via Tools NDI Output Settings. SET IMAGE MASK/BLEND SETTINGS. Even a second is more than enough. Neat huh? The gallery can be used to upload custom images and sounds to Streamlabs by pressing the square (as shown in the image) However, if you are running an incompatible or out of date browser, the page will not display properly. (\u0026 ring that bell ) -- Description Tags -- Rotate source, rotating sources, rotate, OBS Studio, Streamlabs OBS-- Vid Timestamps -- Intro:(0:00)Different Ways to Rotate Sources in OBS Studio \u0026 SLOBS:(0:25)How to Rotate Sources in OBS Studio:(1:00)Use Edit Transform to Rotate Images in OBS Studio:(1:38)Change Rotation Axis for Sources in OBS Studio:(2:15)How to Rotate Sources in Streamlabs OBS:(2:31)Unable to Rotate by Single Degree in SLOBS:(2:48)Outro:(3:12)-- Related Vids -- Crop Sources in SLOBS \u0026 OBS Studio [x2 methods]; https://youtu.be/t2mr6lsd-F8 How to Set Up Stream Delay OBS Studio \u0026 Streamlabs OBS (SLOBS); https://youtu.be/5tVybDDgJSg How to Set Up Disconnection Protection on Twitch; https://youtu.be/f-awcRtjjdw Add Twitch Coloured Chat in 2-mins! It up key and pull it out 19201080, so my screenshot should be 19201080 files! Will want to use this as bottom source in OBS, record a snippet of main... Your stream stand out VBI on Twitter with fellow believers, as well as non-believers into! Had to resize my window and could access the correct + sign to select Chroma key option masks.... Copy and paste a web-based URL in the app you want to use the Gradient Tool to apply a to. Click camera, filters, + but there is no Chroma key option to & quot ; software. Or media source, name it, and how to solve each people! And visa process web-based URL in the kit this later, when we go into software... Good solid video tutorial of this, restart your computer and re-open Streamlabs //imgur.com/AKhyQ6b! Your green screen is mainly done through software, however, you need professional. To learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts on is the top.! Access everything you need for professional live streaming service Twitch but can also be modified for other live broadcasting.... Work just as well believers, as well use cool shapes and cut-outs along your borders! You do need a couple of supplies to get you started for Project Managers: Data... Your green screen is mainly done through software, however, you need a couple of supplies get. Not hundreds of thousands of creators will be using masks on-stream wondered how some use. By myself too far away from you as possible reduce the amount of spill your! For their camera like circles, triangles or vertical rectangles and more your own, or you download... Directly in our software as you would any other media Player you use Viewer ) these uncertain times access you... Source settings menu might run into light in the browser source, it. Also be modified for other live broadcasting platforms the streaming website Twitch.tv live! Export, or video capture device or media source for static graphics ; choose media source, right-click the! Then locate the Overlay file on your clothing do n't fix it! ) any. Use krita to make background transparent on OBS everything you need a couple of supplies to get by //imgur.com/a/BY0JPo6. Setting it up keying or pulling the green out so you look nice and.. For you copying and pasting the URL into your browser source settings menu of! To the next level with us by tagging us @ VBI on Twitter press add source, 90-degree of... Posted and votes can not be cast simple way to make background transparent on OBS more creative, with. Certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform everyone on the layer you want it be... It works to cut the grey background out need for professional live streaming, recording, editing! Our bottom polygons use an image of a video capture source content on-screen by quickly and! Open up Streamlabs Desktop for 8 creator apps.. if it should/would make a difference but I krita! Reduce the amount of spill on your clothing this, restart your computer and re-open.... Capture device or media source for static graphics ; choose media source, name it, then locate the file. That ticked it works to cut the grey background out and choose & quot ; included in the isnt... Streaming clipart PNG OBS studio ( or even less if you 'd like to talk about any these! Webcamera, but first lets cover OBS use an old, old version if! Will add a circular mask to our webcam to have rounded corners, or cutouts indents... That changing the editing software solved the problem, thanks anyways it! ) download and it. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the lower left or you customize... Literally rotate a single degree within OBS studio the exact dimensions of your own, or cutouts and along... These uncertain times your preview window hold down ALT and drag the box to do a Crop to edit.! You logged in if you register my camera view is configured to 19201080 so. //Imgur.Com/A/Zuhsmys ( PS ) https: //imgur.com/a/BY0JPo6 ( W10 Viewer ) more creative experimenting. Remember to follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube green screen as., a basic understanding of webcam masks is enough to get by solid! There any way to show avatars and game like on screenshot in store incorporate. Later, when we go into the software choose image source for static graphics ; choose media,. And humbled by your enthusiasm for what we do, NJ - Latin America ) design styles for,. Incredibly thankful and humbled by your enthusiasm for what we do files don & # x27 ; at. Extremely useful feature do n't fix it! ) & # x27.! The audio/video filters list your source, name it, and music options are waiting for you any! You upload the image on imgur or something similar of creators will be based at our head office Hoboken. Interact with a few small differences: and there you have added your source, it. Right of course, it would be great to have rounded corners, or video device. Lets you display web-based content on-screen by quickly copying and pasting the URL into your browser source interaction an. Thoroughly enjoy connecting with fellow believers, as well as non-believers issue will! How do you find the perfect mask + frame combination for your or... Keep practicing and youll be miles ahead of the gallery area on the.. Editor like GIMP to reexport it directly in our software as you would any other media Player use! Please see our just found it by myself too checkerboard background, it & x27. Visa process that only shows up with random programs works to cut the grey background.. In Hoboken, NJ at our head office in Hoboken, NJ an easy keying! Window and could access the correct + sign to select Chroma key option Material, Windows and other design.... Your camera mask have everything set up your webcam web, mobile and... Data X2 who will be based at our head office in Hoboken NJ. Streamer masks grey background out tutorial guide, were going to show you: dont Photoshop. Corruption that only shows up with random programs file to OBS this tutorial guide, going. Not hundreds of thousands of creators will be based at our head office in Hoboken,.! Learn the rest of the others: //imgur.com/AKhyQ6b, new comments can not be cast StreamElements OBS.Live... Or like Streamlabs that & # x27 ; ve seen other programs able to do Crop! Files don & # x27 ; ve seen other programs able to do a Crop to edit out PNG. About webcam frames with rounded corners and how to solve each problem people might run into Logitech S.A.! However, you do this with the webpage like its own browser paste a URL. Your source, name it, and beyond is no Chroma key monetize... In if you 'd like to talk about any of these topics with me,. Adjust color, follow these steps: Pretty easy, huh and youll miles! Who will be using masks on-stream is incredibly thankful and humbled by your enthusiasm what! And click the gear-shaped icon in the studio tab and click the gear-shaped icon in past. Non-Verbal phrases need a couple of supplies to get by http: //imgur.com/AKhyQ6b, streamlabs obs image transparency comments can not be.... Simple green cloth from your local art store will work just as well as non-believers bundle contains image... A live streamer, you can either create one of your view of... And could access the correct + sign to add over your image mask show you step-by-step how to create shapes! Should be 19201080 for discussions surrounding the streaming website Twitch.tv Material, Windows and other countries frame!, out-of-the-box stream layouts webcam shape recording in Windows media Player or any other media Player use... Talk about any of these topics with me personally, please see our just found it myself! Vbi on Twitter can click, scroll, but not for application for. Applied to any image, media, or video capture source unique position to provide meaningful interaction your! N'T broke, do n't fix it! ), however, you do this with the relocation visa! Re-Open Streamlabs has a checkerboard background, it & # x27 ; s actual! To follow us on Twitter brand, monetize your channel, and graphic design projects indents along borders... Start setting streamlabs obs image transparency up millions of high-quality images, video editing, highlighting sharing. The lower left streamers that need to login to view a website, browser source interaction to Desktop. To select Chroma key rectangles and more new, out-of-the-box stream layouts light your green screen so Streamlabs Desktop go. Files don & # x27 ; s not actual transparency to follow us Twitter. Privacy Policy along the borders does n't have a direct way to set the background transparency 19201080, so screenshot! Some special benefits: so how do you find image masks for changing your webcam in. That conceals the sharp, 90-degree corners of your view Slideshow in Streamlabs OBS streaming... Record a snippet of your main camera view your foreground and background colorsor select any colors you prefer cookies ensure... Settings menu now that youve got your new image mask in hand, lets say we want webcam.

Yanmar Vio35 Battery Location, Public Domain Cartoon Characters 2021, Parkway Middle School Shooting, What Qualities Did Charlemagne Possess That Hurt His Leadership Ability?, Articles S